Pearce Godwin Talks about the Development of the Bridging Field and Why it Still Matters -- Full Interview

I (Heidi Burgess) talked with Pearce Godwin on October 28, 2026. Pearce is the founder of the Listen First Project and the ListenFirst Coalition of over 500 organizations working in what has become known as the "bridging field." Two years ago, he stepped away from Listen First to start doing local, place-based bridging work with Urban Rural Action, particularly in his home state of North Carolina, but also elsewhere around the country.  

At the beginning of the interview, Pearce laid out the severity of the problem of polarization in the United States with a lot of statistics.  When I asked him to send me links to his sources, he did, but he also shared this page which lists many more details about the polarization problem beyond what he talked about.

Go to the BI Newsletter on this Interview

 

You can download this video from Vimeo for offline viewing. Click the "V" for video controls, including full screen.

 

 

Heidi Burgess: Hi, I'm Heidi Burgess with Beyond Intractability, and I'm here today with Pearce Godwin, who is really one of the founders of the bridging field. He started Listen First, I believe in 2017, and was there for — well, I was thinking a decade, but it's not 2027 yet — maybe eight years, and then moved on to Urban Rural Action in North Carolina. He's now working locally in North Carolina and also doing some national work with Urban Rural Action, which we'll talk about. Pearce, do you want to talk first about how you got into the field and where Listen First came from, and how it all got going?

Pearce Godwin: Absolutely, Heidi. It'd be my pleasure. And thank you so much for having me and for all that you and Guy do to inform this movement. It was actually 13 years ago, in July of 2013, that I climbed onto an overnight bus in Kampala, Uganda. I looked forward to sleeping through the bumpy trip and then being mesmerized by all the animals that I'd find on safari before returning home. But I didn't sleep. I couldn't sleep. I was too disturbed thinking about the rancor and the vitriol that I'd be coming home to in America. And again, that was 2013 — quaint times, of course, relative to what we're experiencing today.

A little bit of background: I grew up in small-town North Carolina. Perhaps of interest to any other college sports fans in your audience, I was a rabid North Carolina Tar Heel fan as a kid, and then did the unthinkable and went to Duke for college. I joined the dark side. But at this point we've had Duke and Carolina tweeting and talking about Listen First, so talk about bridging divides! I don't know why any of the other divides should be any problem for us! 

I'd always been interested in politics. So after graduating with a public policy major, I went up to D.C. and began my career on Capitol Hill, working for Republican Senator Elizabeth Dole. Just four months in, North Carolina fired me, as Senator Dole lost re-election, and it was a bit of a desert for Republicans on the Hill following the '08 election. So, lacking opportunities there, I spent the next four years just across the river as a national political consultant, doing voter micro-targeting for major Republican campaigns coast to coast, including the 2012 presidential campaign.

I then decided it was time to go back home to North Carolina. But on the way down Interstate 95, I took a little-known exit over to Uganda, as I mentioned, for six months with Samaritan's Purse, a Christian international relief organization. In Uganda, I was in a place of abject material poverty, but was struck by the incredible relational wealth. And in checking U.S. headlines, I realized that my country was becoming just the opposite: a place of immense material wealth and opportunity, yet relational poverty threatening to tear it all apart.

What really stood out to me, Heidi, is that this wasn't just in what I knew and really loved — I'm so glad I began my career in D.C. — it wasn't just in that political hotbed of D.C., but in communities across the country, including my bless-your-heart backyard of North Carolina, to which I was returning after that stint in Africa. It was wrestling with that juxtaposition that kept me awake on the bus ride. I channeled my distress into writing a blog post called "It's Time to Listen," and I posted it from an internet cafe in Nairobi the next morning.

Little did I know at the time that the fresh perspective I'd gained by stepping outside my comfort zone, by exposing myself to backgrounds and beliefs different from my own, and the space I had on that bus to imagine a different path, would change the course of my life. That humble blog post, just calling on Americans to listen first, to move beyond slander and seek common ground, took off. It was published in major papers across the U.S. and elicited a really enthusiastic response. Encouraged by the resonance, and being a millennial, I said, "Let's start a nonprofit," right? I launched Listen First Project to try to do something about it.

But of course, as your audience knows well, toxic polarization is now hitting close to home, infecting our workplaces, our classrooms, our places of worship, even sports leagues and family vacations. One in five Americans has ended a relationship with a friend or family member due to political differences.

Heidi Burgess: I'm surprised it's that low.

Pearce Godwin: Yeah, right, I am too. Two-thirds of us now actively avoid political conversations with coworkers, friends, or family. The way I look at it, is that Americans are tired of division. They want peace in their family, calm in their community, unity in America, and solutions to problems.

A few more data points that I often share with folks: In a recent survey, "divided" was the word most commonly chosen by Republicans, Democrats, and Independents alike to describe America today. Yet 87% of those Americans surveyed say they're tired of division and agree that polarization is a threat to the United States. When asked about the country's future, "united" was the top quality Americans say they want — again, without variation across party lines. And more than 80% of us say our success as a nation depends on our ability to work together. When I look at all of that data, I feel like the numbers show that the problem of polarization is widely recognized, the stakes are understood, and most Americans long for a different reality.

Heidi Burgess: Let me stop you for a sec. Do you think that the numbers would be the same if you were talking to Washington-based politicians — in terms of "united" being the desired quality, and 80% saying that our success depends on our ability to work together?

Pearce Godwin: I don't. I think those of us closest to the heat, if you will — as I was, although it was certainly a tamer time in the first four years of my career — those of us most convinced that "those people" are the enemy, that they are an existential threat, that the next election is the be-all and end-all for me and my kind and my values, those of us who are most absorbed in that polarizing us-versus-them mindset, are likely to be the minority in those national numbers. We're likely to say, "No, we can't work together. We can't possibly work with those people. I don't want to be united with those people; we just have to defeat them."

Heidi Burgess: I think you're right. And I think that's one of the divides that we're not addressing: the Washington elite and everybody else. Everybody else is ready to come together, but we're held apart by the folks in Washington that are spinning a different story and putting that story out through the web and social media. I think there's a divide there that's really big and needs to be addressed, and isn't much. Anyway, that's my observation. Keep going.

Pearce Godwin: Yeah, I think there's a lot of truth in that, Heidi. And the numbers I'll share next, I think, do suggest that the affective polarization — that emotional polarization, not just ideological — has now… I don't know if I want to say it's trickled down, because I think it's such a reinforcing loop. But I think the data here show that it's not, unfortunately, just an elite problem. It's not just their fault. I think a lot of us have begun to really feel that our fellow Americans are the enemy. And I always want to look at myself in the mirror before I point at D.C. or at anybody else.

Given all that — if the problem's understood, if the stakes are understood, if most Americans long for this different reality — why haven't we found a way out of the toxic polarization vortex? It seems to be those people, right? We're always pointing at those people as the problem. But as I was alluding to, 80% of Republicans and Democrats believe that the other party, quote, "poses a threat that, if not stopped, will destroy America as we know it." That's 80% of Americans, so that tells me it's not just the elites. More than three-quarters of voters believe that Americans who strongly support the other side are, quote, "a clear and present danger to our country."

And by the way, on these next two, a little bit of behind-the-curtain: I have some speech elements for when I'm speaking. I did a long 30-minute speech in Phoenix last December, and in my repository of points I keep having to update these, because the numbers keep getting worse. It's now 40% of both Republicans and Democrats who say members of the opposing party lack the traits to be considered fully human.

Heidi Burgess: Whoa. I hope you'll give me a citation for that one!

Pearce Godwin: I absolutely will. It was from Public Agenda, and I've got it linked here and I'm happy to share it with you. And more than half — again, this is both Republicans and Democrats — say members of the opposing party are, quote, "downright evil." That was also Public Agenda, just recently updating some former work that was done on each of those measures.

So toxic polarization, as I mentioned a moment ago, has convinced too many of us that our fellow Americans are our enemies. Heidi, I think that is a lie, and it's a lie that threatens to destroy us. It's been described by experts such as you all, and others have described it as, quote, "a singularly virulent and dangerous phenomenon," and, quote, "our greatest national security vulnerability."

Fear, distrust, and animosity toward those on the other side of the political divide are shackling Americans in our tribal corners. And as far as I can tell, from those corners, it's very hard to get a clear, nuanced, realistic view of the world. Our politics tend to look, as you've written about many times, like a must-win, zero-sum battle between us and them, and the thems look like enemies.

But, a little bit more data. Here's the thing: most Americans don't actually know them, right? 77% of us have few or no friends on that other political side. As my friend Monica Guzmán says, quote, "Whoever is underrepresented in your life will be overrepresented in your imagination. Instead of people, you'll see monsters."

One of the major drivers of toxic polarization, which you've talked about many times, is what my partners at More in Common call perception gaps: the difference between what we perceive another group thinks and what members of that group actually think. More in Common found that, overall, Democrats and Republicans imagine that almost twice as many of their political opponents hold extreme views as actually do. Our false impressions of one another are driven, I think, by balkanized media and politicians who cynically profit from making us outraged.

Other drivers of toxic polarization, I think, are perversions of otherwise good instincts. At a time when religious faith and practice are declining, these corners and their crusades can give us a sense of calling, a sense of higher purpose and righteousness. At a time when so many Americans report feeling lonely and isolated, these tribal corners can feel quite warm, fulfilling our human craving for belonging and community.

And look, Heidi, I get it. As I wrote in Time magazine a couple years ago, as a guy who's worked to improve social cohesion for more than a decade, I'm disturbed by my own hypocrisy and vulnerability. I, too, have a strong need to belong, yet I sometimes feel politically homeless and lonely outside that us-versus-them binary — lonely, but still in the line of fire. Personally, I often feel ostracized and repelled by demonization of conservatives or Christians or white guys. And frankly, I understand the temptation to latch onto a tribe, to come in from the cold and find belonging in battle. But you and I know that if we give in to that temptation, we all lose, and the exceptional experiment that is America will fail.

There's a recent Gallup poll from last year on U.S. democracy that offers additional perspective and some encouragement. 80% say, quote, "political leaders should compromise with the other party to get things done, even if they don't like some parts of the compromise." And that view is shared by at least 75% of Republicans, Democrats, and Independents, compared to only 18% who say, quote, "political leaders should stick to their beliefs and avoid compromise, even if little gets done."

84% say that the U.S. is stronger as a nation because it has people from different races, religions, and cultures. Again, it'd be very easy for any of us as partisans to say, "Yeah, my side thinks that, but I know the others don't." But again, this view is shared by at least 75% of Republicans, Democrats, and Independents. 80% agree that, quote, "everyone, regardless of their views, has the right to free, nonviolent expression." Finally, 83% say, quote, "it is never okay for people to use violence to achieve a political goal." Now, a concerning caveat on that one is that only 69% of younger Americans, age 18 to 29, agree with that statement, with 30% of them believing, quote, "it is sometimes okay for people to use violence as a way to achieve a political goal." [All these numbers come from the same Gallup poll.]

So, back to my story and this work over the years. 2017, as you noted, was an important year in my own personal milestones. In 2013, having written the blog post, I came home and was in a marketing job in Raleigh, North Carolina. For those first four years, the Listen First Project was just Pearce's pajamas project: a little bit of speaking, a little bit of writing, but certainly not any tremendous impact. But it was in 2017, as you mentioned, four years after writing "It's Time to Listen" and returning home from Africa, that I realized I wasn't alone on this mission. And as you well know, that set the course from there.

At the time, I recognized that there were a few others bringing Americans together across divides to build understanding, trust, relationships, and solutions, to turn down the heat and find a way forward together. I felt like those of us doing that work could have a greater impact together. So I launched Listen First Project and the Listen First Coalition with four organizations. Today there are more than 550 organizations in our Listen First Coalition, and over the years these groups have partnered locally, nationally, and in key social sectors to drive that greater impact together.

Listen First Project came to understand ourselves as serving as the backbone organization for the movement. That's jargon from collective impact theory, and there are some great cases in other movements and causes over the years. As that backbone organization, since we founded the coalition in 2017, Listen First Project has sought to build community and coordination, to amplify hope and opportunity, and to assess impact. 

The North Star of the bridging divides movement — and this was established by the Bridging Movement Leadership Council three or four years ago — is that we will thrive as a nation because of our ability and willingness to work together across differences. Again: that we will thrive as a nation because of our ability and willingness to work together across differences.

Now, here's the time for reflection, as I think about the decade-plus that I've spent on this mission. I've described my experience, Heidi, as both humbling and hopeful. There's a lot to unpack on both sides, but in brief, on the humbling side of the coin, attempts at big national campaigns have not attracted as many people as we'd hoped. We've had partnerships that we've been really excited about — a deep partnership with USA Today, and then support from Walmart, Target, Dick's Sporting Goods, McDonald's, Harley-Davidson, all of these big, bold names, and some significant resources. But be that as it may, attempts at big national campaigns have not attracted as many people as we'd hoped. I've seen, of course, that many people distrust invitations to bridge divides, especially my fellow conservatives, something I've written about extensively in the Chronicle of Philanthropy. And, of course, toxic polarization… yeah, go ahead.

Heidi Burgess: Let's talk about that a little bit, because I've talked to a lot of organizations that say they're neutral, but in reality, we all know they're somewhat left-leaning. And they all complain that they can't get conservatives to come to their events. Why is that, and what can be done about it?

Pearce Godwin: I appreciate that question, and I'm happy to share my headline points from that piece in the Chronicle of Philanthropy. The article was called "You Need Conservatives. Here's How to Engage Them in Your Mission." Some of this is based on my own conservative perspective. Other points have been revealed to me by field veterans and heroes such as Liz Joyner at Village Square, who herself is a proud liberal, but feels so adamantly, from both a moral and a strategic perspective, that, as I often say, if we're not engaging our fellow Americans of all backgrounds and beliefs, we are at best on a futile mission, and at worst we're, indeed, exacerbating the problem.

So, the insights about my fellow conservatives. I'm going to resist the urge to editorialize on all these; we can get more into it, and it's all in that article. Conservatives tend to be less enthusiastic about change of any kind. Conservatives tend to believe in different change agents than liberals. Just to explain that a bit: as a conservative, I might be more interested in the market or my faith community, whereas liberals are perhaps more interested in government and the nonprofit sector. So — guilty as charged — a nonprofit leader showing up is automatically going to lead to a bit of suspicion, just because conservatives tend to believe in different change agents.

Conservatives tend to have a tighter circle of concern. I said I was going to resist editorializing, but I'll make it quick. This one was from Liz, and I want to credit her with it, Liz Joyner at Village Square. She said, "Pearce, I've noticed that when we invite folks to come, conservatives are kind of like, 'I'm good.'" Maybe they've got their church small group, their Rotary club, their traditional nuclear family, and they're just like, "I'm good. I'm not feeling a need for new friends or to meet strangers." And that, I think, is something quite interesting about the tighter circle of concern, as opposed to a liberal perspective traditionally having a more global — which of course has become a pejorative in the conversation — but more of that broad-based concern. That's important to know.

Conservatives tend to distrust and suspect what the social activists are selling. Also, conservatives often feel marginalized, misunderstood, harshly judged, looked down upon — I'd say culturally marginalized, and canceled, if you will, in recent years. I think that's a really important, practical thing for all of us, conservative, liberal, moderate, to understand. While we might not have experienced it, what I hear again and again from my fellow conservatives is, "I feel burned from this one time that I tried to have a conversation, and I was harshly judged, looked down upon, called this, that, and the other epithet." So that matters.

And then, finally, conservatives hear liberal signals — i.e., language — a mile away, and often run the other direction. That one is so hard. I don't want to take our time on it now, but I have a whole list of terms and alternatives. They aren't bad terms; as I scan the list in my mind, there's a lot of goodness in most, if not all, of the terms that can be heard as liberal signals. It's simply that we all fall into the habit of using the language that is most commonplace within our tribe, within the folks we hang out with. And that is heard, not substantively, but as, "Okay, I know who you are because you use this term, and I think you're probably not welcoming of me, so I won't come."

So those are my insights on fellow conservatives, on the "why." On the what to do about it — steps to better engage conservatives — again, there's a paragraph or two on each of these in the Chronicle of Philanthropy, and I'm happy to share a link to it for the audience. First, embrace humility. Second, demonstrate real curiosity in and appreciation for what conservatives bring to your mission, if you're not a conservative yourself. Invite conservatives to actively help achieve goals you share and co-create solutions to problems they care about. Don't seek agreement on issues unrelated to the mutual goal; those litmus tests or purity tests are not necessarily going to be helpful to the mission at hand. Make your mission relevant to a tighter circle of concern, understanding that those of us who are conservative tend to see that tighter circle of concern as more salient and of interest to us. Avoid words that close down the opportunity to connect. Connect on values that tend to be especially salient for conservatives.

Find and cultivate ambassadors — I love to call these trusted validators — somebody of that group that is not your own, who can vouch for you. A real quick anecdote from a project I was piloting in Kentucky: we were having lunch with Susan, who was participating in this pilot, and Susan was very conservative. I said, "Susan, what brought you to be a part of this?" She said, "I would have never come to this thing in a million years. It sounds liberal, I'm sure Soros is behind it, yada yada. But then Becky in my Sunday school class said she was doing it. And I thought to myself, if Becky's doing it, it's all right. I think I can trust it; I'll come too." That's a trusted validator. So I think finding and cultivating those ambassadors is critical. And my final piece of advice is to get uncomfortable and meet conservatives on their turf.

So that, in headline form, is my thinking on that really sticky challenge of engaging Americans of all backgrounds and beliefs, especially those where, if we look at our field and our participants, there can be some glaring gaps at times. Whether it's from a moral perspective or a pragmatic perspective, that's just not going to cut it. And again, at worst it could make the very problem we're trying to solve worse, if we become our own little choir, our own homogeneous little tribe that itself can take on those us-versus-them dynamics that are so hard for all of us to suppress, because we're human.

But anyway, back to the humbling side of the coin. Again, attempts at big national campaigns have not attracted as many people as we'd hoped. I've seen that many people distrust invitations to bridge divides, as we just talked about; that's especially true of my fellow conservatives, in addition to other demographic groups of our fellow Americans. Certainly violence is increasing. Some of the most active in our politics and culture have turned their backs on America's founding vision of prospering as one, and instead focus on destroying the other.

And finally, on the humbling side of the coin for me, many of our fellow Americans have lost hope for a way out. Heidi, over the early years, I knew I was fighting against my own worst instincts, right? That deeply ingrained biological inclination for belonging, and fear of threat, and that us versus them, fear of being ostracized — all the biology. I got that. I knew we were fighting that within ourselves, and in the way we can view our fellow Americans. But what I've come to understand more in recent years is that so many of our fellow Americans have just lost hope for a way out. They're apathetic, and we get the pat on the head — I'm sure you've gotten the pat on the head, Heidi — like, "Good luck with that. That's really nice. I'm glad you're working on that." But so many people just don't even think it's possible.

So with that, I'll turn to the hopeful side of the coin, for me, reflecting over the last decade-plus. I've witnessed rapid growth of the movement. Look, 550 organizations in the Listen First Coalition sounds impressive, but our coalition is only the tip of the iceberg. I'm much more encouraged by the fact that there's a wellspring of efforts toward peace and unity in communities, places of worship, classrooms, and workplaces across America. As I tell folks, if you believe that America is a country worth fighting for, and that the only way forward is together, you are not alone.

Another point of hope for me is that we've measured real personal impact on those who participate in bridging initiatives. I often tell folks that again and again, we see that when people come to that proverbial table, the magic happens. I think it's how we're wired. It's that reciprocal nature of a human interaction; that thing is deeply ingrained in us. But of course, as we talked about a moment ago, getting our fellow Americans, and a representative set thereof, to the proverbial tables is increasingly challenging every day, because of the very problem we're trying to solve. But for those who participate in bridging initiatives, we have measured that real impact.

Heidi Burgess: Let me stop you again. Have you measured whether that impact lasts? Yes, people will say it was a really good experience, and I really got to understand the people who were there. But does that translate into changing one's long-term or permanent attitude about the other side in general? So you go from thinking the other side is evil to thinking the other side is more like me, not so bad, good even? Or is it just Joe and Alice and Nancy, who I met at that table, and they're different, because most people on the other side really are still evil?

Pearce Godwin: Yeah, excellent question, Heidi, and you touch on a couple of points there. One is contact theory: Is it extrapolated out from Joe and Nancy, who I may have had a conversation with? Our data would suggest that it is. The other point you raise is the stickiness of that impact, right? Is there durability to that impact? That is the next, and I think now current, question that more and more research is being done around.

The Bridging Movement Goals and Measures program, which is housed at Listen First Project and supported by New Pluralists — our social cohesion impact measurement (SCIM) tools, which are used by dozens of organizations across the bridging field — has found that interventions across the field have had the most meaningful impact on outcomes such as valuing listening, affective polarization, self-efficacy to bridge divides, self-efficacy to create a bridging community, anger, respect and understanding, and intellectual humility. But most of those findings, Heidi, to your question, are from pre- and post-surveys, so immediately after. More recently, we're seeing research come out a few weeks later, a few months later. I think we have a lot of work to do to ensure the durability of that impact.

It's very encouraging to see what happens there, but I'm always reminded of my pastor, who says, "Look, I get y'all for one hour on Sundays, and there are 168 hours in the week. If y'all are going back to Facebook or to your favorite cable news host, that's going to be tough." And indeed, the research suggests that any of us who swim in some kind of fresh waters — "Oh, we can do this. This is great. My spirits are lifted. I have hope. I no longer see those people, the other side, with such a sense of fear and threat and animosity" — if we then dip our heads right back down into our echo chambers, it's not going to last long. I think that is a very real and valid concern and critique of the work, and I've heard it called dosing.

This is not going to happen — we'll get into this, I'm sure, later — by the 550 organizations in the coalition becoming 50,000 organizations and programmatically inviting people in like that. That's not going to happen. I think that's a very encouraging and critical way to build skills, and to have those hopeful opportunities that open our eyes, that there can be a way out, there can be a better way to live. But ultimately this has got to be about culture change, and I know we'll get into that in a bit.

Still, my third point on the hopeful side is the growing body of research that now guides our work. I've talked about some of it already, and you all have written about it a lot, but the ones that are quite salient to me as actionable insights are from More in Common's Connection Opportunity Report, finding that, quote, "Americans are most interested in working across lines of difference to achieve a mutual goal that improves their community." Similarly, people say the condition that would make them most eager to connect across lines of difference is, quote, "if we had a common goal we were working towards."

Along the very same lines, the Trust for Civic Life found, in a survey of rural community members, that, quote, "taking action with other community members to achieve a specific outcome, whether around an everyday problem or a more formal community-wide issue, was strongly tied to feelings of trust, agency, and belonging." That all backs up research that I conducted back in 2022 for one of those big campaigns. And I found out, Heidi — I knew I was weird, but just how weird I am. Not that many people want to listen first and meet strangers and really come to better understand different perspectives. They just have other things on their minds. But across every demographic group, the most compelling framing for this kind of opportunity was, quote, "an opportunity to work together to fix things we broadly agree are broken." You and I agree on a pothole; we want to fix it. So this more recent research from our friends at Trust for Civic Life and More in Common substantiates what we were seeing in that market testing a few years ago. 

Also, the More in Common report — again, we're talking about research that is now informing our work — found that intergroup anxiety, the fear of having an awkward or uncomfortable interaction with someone from a different group, is the strongest impediment to connection across differences. And, shocker to your audience, Americans are most apprehensive about connecting across political difference. More in Common found that those fears include that the interaction will be uncomfortable, that they would be misunderstood, and indeed personal safety. That's where we are.

Now, the final point on the things that have made me really hopeful over the last decade: I've gotten a lot of hope from seeing meaningful transformation at the local community level. As my friend Daniel Stid has observed, on the one hand, our national politics and governing institutions continue to spiral downward in a doom loop of polarization, dysfunction, and delegitimization. On the other, we can observe green shoots of promise and pluralism in many communities across the country, as Americans join forces to tackle challenges they face.

And Heidi, as you mentioned in your introduction of me, it's that last point — seeing the greatest impact at the local level — that inspired me to shift focus from my national movement backbone role, to pass that backbone leadership baton to Karissa, my deputy at Listen First Project, so that I could work on the front lines of the mission in local communities, including my own. I was very blessed to have familiarity with so many different models out there, and across the Listen First Coalition I've seen countless impactful efforts toward social cohesion and collaboration.

But scanning that landscape, I personally felt like I'd have the greatest impact by joining my friends at Urban Rural Action, because their Uniting for Action local hubs work stands out as so community-led, so action-oriented, genuinely welcoming of divergent perspectives. As you alluded to earlier, some of us can be challenged in that, despite our best intentions, but Urban Rural Action is so genuinely welcoming of those divergent perspectives, and inclusive of rural communities — it's in the name, right? I also found Urban Rural Action's tools to be highly accessible, and so practical and memorable as a foundation for collaboration skills. The work is measurable.

And my favorite — I've written about this a lot — it's fun. I'm always out there thinking, "Golly, am I asking folks to eat their broccoli?" I'm not a guy who loves broccoli. But instead of eating broccoli, in our Uniting for Action programs we have our Uniters literally doing cheese and chocolate truffle tastings. So we're staying as far away from broccoli as we possibly can, and that idea of having fun is one of the guiding principles of Urban Rural Action. So that drew me to UR Action.

For those who may not know, Urban Rural Action is a place-based national nonprofit organization working in communities around the country, bringing Americans together across divides to tackle urgent local problems. Our Uniting for Action local hubs empower communities to increase social cohesion, boost civic participation, and strengthen local institutions — in short, to make communities safer and stronger. In those local hubs, three things happen. Uniting for Action programs bring Americans together to solve problems across differences where they live. Community workshops in third spaces strengthen civic participation skills. And finally, community leadership labs — we call them co-labs — equip local leaders to work collaboratively and make institutions more responsive.

I joined Urban Rural Action at the beginning of last year, in January of 2025. This year, I've been leading a Uniting for Action program in southwestern Pennsylvania, as I seek funding to do it here at home in eastern North Carolina. In those Uniting for Action programs, which I said are the first pillar of our local hub model, we bring community members together across several counties and over several months, across the full spectrum of differences, to, one, build relationships; two, strengthen collaboration skills; and three, tackle local challenges together. In short, that's neighbors working together across differences to fix what's broken, to make their communities stronger.

I'm also happy to share my own realizations over the years, from the national movement backbone leadership role and the last couple of years with Urban Rural Action, regarding the indispensable role and unique promise of local work on this mission to bridge divides across America — and we'll get to that trend in a few minutes. My observation, Heidi, is that change moves at the speed of trust, and trust moves at the speed of relationships. Meaningful relationships, especially across differences, develop best when people are in proximity to one another. This is just a thing we know, as humans who have lived on this planet. But with the forces of toxic polarization making us feel further and further apart, finding literal common ground — like a shared neighborhood, town, or county — can be an increasingly effective starting point for this work.

I think local work is also more insulated from the outrage industrial complex that's running rampant at the national level. I find that caricatures of other people promoted by cable news and social media are much more likely to ring hollow if you actually know those other people by name. I think polarizing issues become less frightening when you're working across divides to fill potholes in your own local community.

Now, here's a fun little bit that I recently discovered, speaking of local. Lauren and I moved to New Bern, North Carolina, a couple of years ago, coinciding with the calling I was feeling to work locally — to spend more time on front porches than on Zoom, as I said in my announcement to the field. When George Washington visited my hometown of New Bern following the American Revolution, I discovered, he wrote a letter to the people right here in little old New Bern, saying, quote, "Pleasing indeed is the anticipation of what we may still attain and long continue to enjoy. A bountiful providence has blessed us with all the means of national and domestic happiness." Here's the kicker: "To our own virtue and wisdom, we are referred for their improvement and realization."

Not necessarily the way we would talk today, Heidi. But I reflected on that and on the fact that we've recently marked 250 years since America was founded on an idea, right? We were founded, as you've written about many times, not on a common ethnicity, or race, or religion, but on these ideals of freedom, liberty, opportunity, equality, and justice. An experiment, a bet, right? That's what this is: a big, grand experiment and bet that a collection of people from a wide variety of backgrounds and beliefs would be able to work through their differences enough to live peaceably and govern themselves — that out of many, we could become one. E pluribus unum, that national motto.

So when that bet is not looking so good, as it's not right now, and when I personally see toxic polarization and political violence escalating to a horrifying level, when I feel my hope threatened on this mission — and I'm a pretty upbeat, enthusiastic guy, especially about this work — I remind myself of two key things. Number one, there is a growing movement of patriotic Americans lighting a way out. And two, I, Pearce Godwin, have the power to control my own individual heart, mind, and actions.

I suggest to folks that as an outrage industrial complex actively stirs up our most base instincts and poisonous passions, this bridging divides movement provides inspiration, skills, and opportunities for a different path; that we and all who show up on this mission illuminate what is possible and what is better. I encourage folks that if they want a way out of the toxicity damaging our families and communities and country, if they're ready to work together for a stronger future, they can find their hope and opportunities in the bridging divides movement. A great starting place is conversation.us, which we developed a few years ago as kind of a front door for the field. At conversation.us, the coalition offers a range of resources from across our hundreds of partners that are designed to help individual Americans — your friends, your family — take the first step down that better path.

And then, in closing, I think America's destiny will be determined by the choices and actions of individual Americans, including you and me, Heidi. Will we put patriotism and pragmatism above our partisan passions? Will we fight against our fellow Americans in an escalating conflict that we all lose? Or will we fight for America? So my challenge to myself, and to everyone in your audience, and everyone across the country, is to hope; then to plant your feet firmly against the current of contempt and combat; to root yourself in community defined by common aspirations, rather than a common enemy; to resist rage and get grounded in family, friends, and neighbors.

Because if you're anything like me, it is so easy to go with the flow, right? To get whipped up into a frenzy, or to duck down and disengage, surrendering our future to destructive forces. It takes courage to choose a different path, to use the real influence you have in the groups you're in to be a countercultural leader. As my friend David Brooks says, quote, "Culture changes when a small group of people find a better way to live, and the rest of us copy them."

Heidi Burgess: Convincing. Good line. And it still has me worried, for a couple of reasons. One is, I totally believe what you're saying about local, for all sorts of reasons. But we can get lots of successful localities doing wonderful things, and the whole will still break apart. America is not going to survive, and Americans are not going to survive, if every little entity is thriving on its own, but we can't hold it together. Because we're too interactive now. We need stuff from other states, we need stuff from all over the world, and we can't just isolate.

I, too, will admit I have written lots of things that say we've got to focus on the local. My hope — but truth be known, I'm not sure I believe the hope — is that if localities start working well enough, people at the national level will say, "Well, look what they're doing. We ought to do it the same way." That's my hope, but I'm not sure I really believe it's going to happen.

Pearce Godwin: Same here.

Heidi Burgess: So I still think that our field has to figure out how to engage at the national level successfully. And it's hard. I understand you're saying that it hasn't worked that well, so we ought to go local. But I really think we still have to try to figure out how we're going to hold this national experiment together, because we all are dependent on it. If it falls apart, we're all going to be in horrible shape, even if your town in North Carolina and my Boulder, Colorado, are doing great on their own. It won't last long.

Pearce Godwin: Yes, ma'am.

Heidi Burgess: So that's one of my fears. The other one — and on this, I think you and I are on the same side, but I haven't successfully defended that side yet — is the comeback from so many of our colleagues. It was David Beckemeyer who used the words, in our newsletter: Are you "fiddling while Rome burns?" Talk's wonderful, but the country's burning down.

There's a bunch of folks, I'm sure you know, who have this fourfold rubric of bridge, block, build, and belong. And there are a lot of folks who are saying the time has come to block. We can't focus on this bridging, or building, or belonging; we've got to block. But blocking divides. So I'm trying to block the blockers, and not doing all that well. What do you see as the answer to: Are we fiddling while Rome burns?

Pearce Godwin: Yeah. I was so grateful for David's perspectives and the opportunity to engage in conversation with him on that, and for your generosity in publishing the conversation. I think my answer to that is similar to what I'm thinking around local and national: I think there's a both/and. I hope I was never so arrogant — I'm certainly not now, after all that I've experienced, and the scars from seeking quicker or more rapidly scaling solutions to this problem — I absolutely do not think that bridging divides is the be-all and end-all.

What I do think is that bridging — what you might think of as the social and cultural repair — is critically necessary, but insufficient. I think institutions, structures, and incentives are critical as well. As you recently wrote in Newsletter 501, you talked about the four simple, fairly obvious rules that could help a lot with that tit-for-tat positive feedback loop — which, as you pointed out, is actually negative — the escalating reactions. And in those rules, your last one was "refuse to demonize," right? And I think that is absolutely mission-critical.

I've heard the arguments, and I love and respect many of the people who have determined that bridging is too bottom-up, that it's too soft. I certainly respect that passion. I tend to start and often end from a pragmatic perspective. I just don't know how we can possibly move forward together as a nation by further fracturing ourselves.

In USA Today some years ago — because my love language is alliteration — I had this formulation around delusion, doom, duck, and dash. What I've seen, as people say, "That's nice, but not with those people; we can't do it with those people," is that there seems to be an animating belief sometimes that we are just going to somehow overpower those people. We are going to somehow defeat their values, their ideas, their votes. I think that's delusional, given what I think is a fantastic variety of backgrounds and beliefs here in the United States. The math just doesn't add up for me.

I also think that if any of us are saying we've got to defeat this leader, then I'm rather convinced that any leader we have a problem with is a symptom of the culture and society that we've created. I already talked about how it's discouraging and has given me despair to see how some leaders have turned those instincts up to a thousand. I get it; leaders can be more helpful, or quite harmful, in that. But I don't think defeating any leader is going to get us out of the toxic stew that has been created — again, by some of the things that our dear friends and critical partners working on structural reform, working on institutions, working on incentives, are addressing.

But for me, in one sense, I just know the part of the equation that keeps me up at night. And for me, just one guy, it is that demonization across differences. It is seeing our fellow Americans as enemies. It is relationships breaking down at the community and family level. So that is my lane. That's the lane I feel called to. That is not to say it's the most important lane, but it's the lane I feel called to.

From a pragmatic perspective, I just have a really hard time tracing the path, the endgame, that is about pitting us further against each other and ratcheting up the sense of fear and threat. Even if it's a leader or an ideology, whatever anyone thinks it is, I think on either side there are too many of our fellow Americans who deeply believe these things for it to be that simple. So I don't know how inflaming the animosity and the distrust and the sense of threat can do anything but exacerbate the problem and turn up the heat.

And I do understand and want to give full credence to those who point out that sometimes you need more polarization to focus energy on a problem. I fully understand and accept that. I just think, for one thing, given how evenly divided we are now, especially when it comes to a presidential vote and our political system, we're often talking about a giant share — somewhere between a third and a half of our fellow Americans — as the problem. I don't see how that cuts it.

To finish the D's quickly: that's delusion. Doom is the folks who say, "You know what, Pearce, there's just no point. We're going to have another hot civil war; we're going to have violence." They might be right — who am I to say they're not? — but that's certainly not what I'm going to give in to. Duck — golly, Heidi, I'm tempted by this every single day. Let me just duck down. Let me get out of the national conversation, out of the food fight, and let me just keep that tight circle of concern that we conservatives love, just my friends and family, and let it all go where it goes. Obviously, I don't think all of us civically disengaging is any way for a society to function. And then finally, dash. It's unbelievable how many people have told me, "Yeah, my spouse and I have identified this country that we're going to. We are ready to get out." You've heard it too.

Heidi Burgess: Yes.

Pearce Godwin: So: delusion, doom, duck, and dash. And my challenge is, can we do something that is a more positive and prosperous endgame? I think bridging divides, listening with curiosity, is a critical part of that solution, in addition to the important work that so many of our friends and partners are doing.

Heidi Burgess: Let me change gears considerably now. When we were talking before we started recording, you talked about a new organization or effort you're doing called CLUA that I thought sounded really interesting, and I knew nothing about. So tell us a little bit about that.

Pearce Godwin: Sure, I'm happy to. Urban Rural Action has launched a program that I'm leading on the national level and here in eastern North Carolina called Conservative Leadership for United America. This is what many in your audience may be familiar with as intragroup or in-group work. We describe CLUA as empowering conservative leaders with relationships and skills to strengthen the republic and prevent political violence ahead of the 2026 midterm elections. We're conducting the CLUA program in several of our local hubs — central Arizona, eastern North Carolina here, south central Pennsylvania, southeast Wisconsin — plus other folks who are not in those hubs, who make up our national virtual cohort.

The strategy and thinking may be obvious to some in your audience, but maybe less so to others, so I'll share a little bit of the why. Why just conservatives, with this whole thing about bridging divides? The reason is that, as we've already talked about, the current environment of toxic polarization is destroying trust in our fellow Americans, especially across those lines of political difference. That intergroup anxiety we talked about, which More in Common identified, is keeping us from engaging meaningfully and productively across the political divide.

So our thought at Urban Rural Action around CLUA is that, to shorten the distance between good intentions and concrete action on a problem as urgent as political violence, this program is an opportunity to strengthen relationships and take action among our fellow conservatives, where a higher degree of trust and comfort already exists. The leaders of the program, all of us conservatives ourselves, believe that this approach will best engage and empower a wide array of conservative leaders who hold sincere political convictions but may, as I mentioned earlier, feel burned by ill-fated attempts to engage productively across the political divide in recent years, amid so much demonization. Maybe these folks would never accept, at first blush, an invitation to work immediately across that divide, if they've been so burned.

We also recognize that conservatives tend to be more interested in action than conversation — a stereotype that I think often rings true. So with CLUA, we're really focused on breaking through the dysfunction and actively building more resilient communities. Of course, my passion for over a decade, and the work of Urban Rural Action, is all about working together across the full spectrum of divides. But we also know that working within our groups and having influence within our groups can, number one, shorten that distance and make the invitation more welcoming and palatable to our fellow Americans who may feel burned by the toxicity.

Also, when it comes to influence, there's plenty of research and just human experience. Let's play with my college sports allegiances. If a fellow Dukie suggests that I correct my behavior, or that I try a new restaurant, I'm going to give that a lot more credence than if a Tar Heel walks in and says, "Hey, you need to do this or that." We just know that we'll often have the most influence within our groups.

I'll paint the picture just a little bit with some of the projects we are doing. What's really interesting, Heidi, is that despite everything I just said about shortening the distance and having that in-group influence, in each of the cases — and I'm only going to highlight a couple of them, for the sake of time — the conservative leaders participating in CLUA have said, "Sure, we could have influence on, let's be simplistic, our 50% of the equation here, but we sure would rather have influence across the spectrum. So let's call — that's still a thing people do — let's call our liberal friends, our Democratic counterparts, and let's get together and have conversations and publish them." That's what we're doing in eastern North Carolina. So it's been really interesting, and frankly encouraging, how quickly the conservative leaders have jumped to say, "Okay, that's great. We've built the skills; it's time to take action. We want our fellow Americans who are on the other side of the aisle to be in partnership with us on that."

A couple of things to highlight in the projects that are rolling out now, ahead of the midterms. The national virtual cohort put together a fantastic program, organizing a panel discussion in Washington, D.C., which happened on October 27th, to highlight the destructive firsthand impact of political violence. That panel featured Americans who have lived through political violence and spoke candidly about what it cost them, and why rejecting political violence together is the work in front of all of us.

And you talked about that dosing, Heidi. That's great — a wonderful event, the post-surveys are through the roof — but so what? How do we scale that? How do we make that durable? So in this case, the national virtual cohort of conservative leaders in CLUA is supplementing the recording of that panel with resources that community groups can use to lead structured conversations across differences on political violence, and to unite around a commitment to peaceful participation in our public square. So anybody can watch the recording and then bring the conversation to their community. There's a webpage for that panel and the subsequent resources that I'll be happy to share with you, Heidi, if you'd like to share it.

In Arizona — many in the audience may be familiar with Utah Governor Spencer Cox and his Disagree Better initiative, which we, the Listen First Coalition, partnered with closely while he was National Governors Association chair. In a similar vein, the central Arizona CLUA team has recently launched a new cross-partisan coalition of civic leaders and organizations called Arizona Together, with a series of video conversations designed to remind Arizonans that disagreement does not have to lead to division. Those videos carry one message: that better conversations make for a stronger Arizona. They've got some really great pairs — former members of Congress, state and county officials, local mayors, student leaders. Those very well-produced videos are now being boosted across Arizona, and I'd encourage anybody in the audience who's in Arizona, or just curious, to check out the Arizona Together webpage.

And then finally, just because it's quite different from the first two: the CLUA leaders in south central Pennsylvania determined that one of the causes of political violence risk in their community is people's isolation from others. So they chose to create a project that focuses on encouraging everyone to be better neighbors. They're going upstream, right? In hopes that by building personal relationships with those around you, you'll feel less isolated and more part of the community. The team created a slogan: "Build better neighborhoods. Division is a choice." And with that, and a whole bunch of T-shirts and other good swag, they're attending local events and festivals to share that message, encouraging people to come and talk about what makes a good neighbor.

So that is the CLUA program, my personal and Urban Rural Action's first effort that is in-group, that starts within the group. And I think it's been a fantastic success this year. We already have an interest form for our friends left of center, and we're hoping over the coming years to have a parallel program for left-of-center leaders as well — and then imagine how those would intersect. But again, as hard as it is right now, as tough as this invitation can be, I think there's really something to shortening that leap and starting with a group where you have some shared foundation of values and trust.

Heidi Burgess: Reading between the lines of what you say, I'm hearing that when conservatives recruit conservatives, they're willing to engage, whereas when progressives — or progressives who are pretending to be neutral — recruit conservatives, maybe they don't engage so much.

Pearce Godwin: Absolutely.

Heidi Burgess: But the line that I've heard, that I think you were contradicting, is, "Oh, conservatives aren't interested in doing this kind of thing." It sounds to me like that's not an accurate statement.

Pearce Godwin: Exactly right. That's not an accurate statement, at least in whole. The nuance I'm picking apart there is that if somebody says they aren't interested in doing this kind of thing, that may be 100% true as it's typically practiced and as it's typically messaged, right? If we're not sufficiently conscious of how some of our language may ring with our fellow Americans of a different perspective, then many of us — especially my more liberal friends in the space — may have found that, golly, conservatives don't want to do this kind of thing, and just kind of write it off. But indeed, that's not the case at all.

You heard me use this language earlier, and I think it's brilliant — I didn't come up with it; our local hub in south central Pennsylvania did: talking about "safe and strong communities." If you want to pick apart language like I do and look for those undertones of ideology, certainly a typical, stereotypical conservative ideology may be drawn to a sense of strength, and a sense of security, and a sense of safety. Of course, PACE and More in Common have done fantastic work around talking bridgy — we don't have time for all that — all the words that don't work and all the words that really, really do work, and "community" is one of them. So we're talking about safe and strong communities. That's that narrower circle of concern that a conservative like me might tend to have.

So if we're understanding the work broadly, not just as I might have talked about it before, or the kind of thing I might have invited a conservative to before — 100%, leaning on the sense of patriotism and even reverence that we conservatives might have for the American experiment. Conservatives don't want to see this fail and break down any more than anybody else does. So if we take some of the advice that I shared in that piece in the Chronicle of Philanthropy, then I think we will find that conservatives are just as inclined toward healing this country and fixing what's broken as anybody else. And indeed, my research and others' supports that.

Heidi Burgess: Great. There are a bunch of things that we haven't gotten to, but I think we're coming pretty close to an hour, if we haven't gone over it. Is there anything that you really wanted to share that I haven't asked about?

Pearce Godwin: Yeah. We touched on this in some of what we've talked about, Heidi, but there are trends among practitioners and funders over recent years, and indeed over the decade-plus I've been doing this work. One is conversation to action — not, quote-unquote, "just talking." Now, I will die on the hill that just talking, just having that conversation, is a really important and critical end in and of itself. And I think even better, and more attractive to many of our fellow Americans, to the point of that market research, is if we are moving to action, to problem solving, to filling in a pothole.

And great news: just like talking about local and national, and blocking and bridging, my perspective is both. We're not losing anything in the relationship building if we're moving to action. Indeed, we know from research and experience that moving to action, rolling up our sleeves and working together, strengthens all of those social cohesion and interpersonal outcomes as well. So we're certainly seeing a move toward that.

We're seeing a move toward a local, community-level focus, as we discussed. And we're also seeing a move toward deliberative democracy, with a wellspring of projects. As you know, Heidi, I've been working part-time on one called the Forum, which is piloting in South Carolina, Nevada, and New Hampshire. It has engaged over 100,000 people in the work of identifying a problem in their state that they want to work on fixing, talking about that in community conversations, having a civic assembly, and then going forward — in the phase they're in now — to advocate and advance that work in their state legislature.

So you've got this whole wellspring of deliberative democracy projects. You've got, similar to the Listen First Coalition, a citizen assemblies and deliberation allies network, CADA, that Kristin Hansen stood up and that Matt Byrne at Unify America is now managing. And indeed, my own personal shift and engagements in recent years reflect all three of those trends: conversation to action, local community-level focus, and this wellspring of efforts around deliberative democracy.

I'd also love to very briefly share a couple of insights from the recent second annual in-person Bridging Movement Summit in Kansas City. For the last many years, folks had to put up with me and others for four hours on Zoom every December. But finally, to everyone's relief, last year we first met in person, at George Washington's Mount Vernon. And this year, thanks to American Public Square, a coalition partner, and their incredible generosity in hosting and funding many elements of the second annual in-person Bridging Movement Summit in Kansas City, we had over 100 leaders from the coalition partner organizations there.

Kira, senior director of programs at Urban Rural Action, and I led a plenary session called "Building Consensus on Addressing Common Field Challenges." We surveyed attendees ahead of the summit — again, these are bridging practitioners, leaders of the coalition partners — asking: What is a significant challenge, beyond funding, that you face in this work and see others experiencing as well? Then, in the plenary session, we taught and applied a UR Action tool called the 4D Consensus Building Propeller, which we use with communities and other clients across the country. It's a systematic approach to building consensus. In brief, it's about describing the problem, diagnosing the problem, developing possible solutions, and deciding on next steps.

Perhaps of interest to your audience, I'll just quickly share the common challenges for the bridging divides field identified by these 100-plus leaders who convened in Kansas City: moving from bridging to action; managing burnout; establishing meaningful field collaborations; using language effectively; measuring impact; balancing bridging work with your own convictions; engaging folks on the right; engaging the public beyond, quote, "the choir"; convincing people it's worth their time; and building awareness of what I always call — hat tip to Peter Coleman's awesome book — "a way out."

And then common solutions: we had table breakouts go through the 4D Consensus Building Propeller on all of those, and it was interesting to see the common threads when it got to solutions. Improved messaging; stronger rootedness in local communities; willingness to take risks; paying attention to the data; intragroup as well as intergroup contact; finding a field-wide North Star — not everybody's familiar with the one I shared with you — and then helping each other. So that's some of the work behind the walls of that great Bridging Movement Summit in Kansas City.

And then finally, I would say, if anybody's not familiar with the work of the bridging divides movement, again, conversation.us is a great front door to see the awesome work that coalition partners are doing day in and day out to save America.

Heidi Burgess: Well, Pearce, I'm so glad you're still at it. We've covered a lot of ground. I would like to cover a lot more, so maybe we'll do this again, but for now, thanks so much.

Pearce Godwin: Thank you, Heidi. Honored to be with you. Thank you for your work.

Heidi Burgess: Oh, you're welcome.