|
Introduction:
According to William Steubner, executive director of the
Alliance for International Conflict Prevention and Resolution,
most conflict resolution practitioners tend to approach conflict analysis by
asking why conflict has arisen. However,
in many cases it is more useful to question why there wasn't violent conflict before.
| |
This rough transcript provides a text alternative to audio. We apologize for occasional errors and unintelligible sections (which are marked with ???).
Roots of Conflict
William Steubner
Executive Director, Alliance for International Conflict Prevention and Resolution
| |
Q: Bill Steubner, where do you work and what do you do?
A: I am the executive director of a relatively new group, an umbrella group
for conflict resolution NGOs, it is called the Alliance for International
Conflict Prevention and Resolution. Because that is such a mouthful we just call
it the Alliance.
Q: I wanted to ask you about some thoughts on what questions people should be
asking when they are assessing a conflict situation?
A: Of course every situation is different. My experience has been primarily
in Latin America and the Balkans. Most recently my work has been in the Balkans,
and there, frankly, people didn't ask questions they just listened to very
simplistic ideas. They listened to people that said, "These people have
been fighting for hundreds of year, and it is an intractable conflict."
They listened to people that said, "It is a religious war." Ultimately
they decided that it is just to complicated and said, "We can't figure it
out." I think the most important thing is to come to a real understanding
of the conflict and of the people, because it takes people and what really
motivates them to have a violent conflict. Too often that is not what we do. We
jump in and say that there is conflict here because there is no democracy, so
lets have an election because elections equate to democracy; which is really
nonsense. I think what we have to realize is that every situation is different,
and every situation in it's own way is complex. It takes real studying, real
analysis, and really trying to get to know the people. That is the first step.
Q: Can you tell me what the important question is? And you can tell
me why you think that question is important.
A: I have brought this up many times with practitioners in the field. We tend
to keep asking on the negative side, "Why is there conflict?" Then
looking at that and saying, "How do we eliminate those factors that are
causing violent conflict to bring peace?" What we seem to forget in almost
every society, and the Balkans included, is the vast majority of history shows
that people are not in violent conflict. One way or another they come to an
accommodation. I think that is very important, and one of things that we ought
to be doing is looking back to the periods where there is no conflict, which is
usually the majority of the time and say, "Why wasn't there conflict",
instead of saying "Why is there conflict?" Maybe there is something we
need to get back to, maybe something like in Somalia where you need to get back
to this rule of village and tribal elders which had maintained stability in
Somalia for hundreds of years. Then along come the war lords and the misuse of
humanitarian assistance, which freed more people up for fighting and destroyed
the economy and then actually broke down this old system of why there was peace
and stability.
Q: Can you give me another example like that? Like Somalia, that is a
great illustration.
A: Well, Somalia is a good one. Bosnia is a really good one. What they have
in Bosnia is in every twenty to fifty years, not just in Bosnia but in much of
the Balkans, they have a tremendous blood letting. It may sound silly, but one
of the ways, because it is almost inexplicable, I used to explain it that a
dragon lives in the soil in the Balkans and any twenty to fifty years he wakes
up hungry and he gluts himself on blood. Once he is full he goes back to sleep
for another twenty to fifty years. I think what conflict resolution people
should be doing is look at those periods when he was asleep and say, "We don't
have to put him asleep again how do we kill him? What are the root causes that
don't cause violent conflict all the time but occasionally flare up and then you
have horrible organized conflict?"
|